How to Hire a YouTube Video Editor (Step-by-Step Guide)
You’re ready to get serious about YouTube, but editing takes too much time and energy. If you hire the wrong editor, you’ll spend just as long fixing mistakes, or worse, managing someone who slows you down.
Hiring doesn’t have to be a gamble. In this guide, I’ll show you the exact steps I use to find, test, and keep great editors, so you can focus on growing your business instead of juggling revisions.
Context: Why Hiring the Right Editor Matters
If you run a consulting or coaching business, your YouTube channel can be a high-trust lead source. But only if your content looks professional and gets published consistently.
The wrong editor creates bottlenecks. You deal with delays, amateur results, or endless revision loops. Maybe you’ve already tried Fiverr or Upwork with promises of unlimited revisions, rushed portfolios, and poor communication. The result? Stalled projects and a channel that never gains traction.
The right editor, on the other hand, is a partner. They free your calendar, keep your workflow running, and make your content shine. This guide walks you through a proven process that works at agency scale but can be adapted to any size.
Step 1: Build a Simple Production System
Before you hire an editor, you need a clear production process. Even a basic system will save time, reduce confusion, and set your editor up for success. Without structure, you’ll face missed deadlines and inconsistent publishing, which stalls your YouTube growth.
Think of this as the foundation of your content machine. A simple system ensures your editor knows what to do, when to do it, and how the final result should look. It doesn’t have to be complex, but it must be clear.
Practical steps to set up your system:
- Map out your workflow: scripting, filming, editing, uploading.
- Use simple tools like Google Drive, Trello, or email to stay organized.
- Assign clear roles so no task falls through the cracks.
Step 2: Write a Clear Job Description
Your job post is a filter. A clear post attracts serious editors and saves you hours. Vague posts pull in anyone, which means more screening and weak results.
Write it like a simple spec. Say what you publish, who it serves, and what you expect. Keep it short, human, and easy to act on.
How to make your job post stand out:
- Use a clear title like “Long-form YouTube Video Editor.”
- List deliverables and publishing cadence (e.g., two 8–12 minute videos per week).
- Share examples of styles you like and who your audience is.
- Include required tools, workflow basics, and turnaround times.
- State pay terms and next steps, such as a short paid test.
Step 3: Plan and Offer a Paid Test
The best way to judge an editor is through real work. Portfolios can be misleading, but a short, paid test shows you how they handle your content. It also signals professionalism—you respect their time, and they respect your process.
Here’s how to structure a fair test:
- Keep the test short, such as a 1-minute edit.
- Pay fairly, usually $10–$50 depending on complexity.
- Give every applicant the same clip so results are easy to compare.
- Review for quality, pacing, and attention to detail.
Step 4: Post Your Job in Multiple Places
Relying on one platform limits your options. The best editors may not be where you first look, so casting a wider net helps you find the right fit faster. Each platform has tradeoffs, but spreading your post across several increases both volume and quality.
Where to share your job listing:
- YT Jobs for high applicant volume.
- Upwork for filters, reviews, and built-in project tools.
- Twitter and LinkedIn for referrals and personal networks.
- Track applicants with a simple spreadsheet or project tool.
Step 5: Filter and Screen Applicants
Once applications come in, resist the urge to rush. A little filtering upfront saves hours later. The goal is to quickly sort serious editors from those who look good on paper but won’t deliver.
What to check before moving forward:
- Confirm “video editor” is their main role, not a side skill.
- Look at ratings, reviews, or badges to spot reliable talent.
- Treat portfolios as a filter, not a final decision tool.
- Pay attention to communication style in early messages.
Step 6: Ask the Right Pre-Test Questions
Before you spend money on a test, confirm the basics. A short exchange can reveal whether an editor has the tools, mindset, and reliability you need. This step saves you from paying for tests with people who were never a real fit.
Key questions to cover upfront:
- Can they edit in your preferred software and follow your workflow?
- Are they comfortable with your deadlines and process?
- What are their rates, and how do they prefer to be paid?
- Do they understand expectations around revisions and ownership?
Step 7: Run the Paid Test
This is where you see who can actually deliver. A well-structured test reveals not only editing skill, but also attention to detail and ability to follow instructions. Keep it simple, consistent, and easy to compare across candidates.
How to run the test effectively:
- Send every applicant the same raw clip.
- Ask for a short finished edit, no longer than 1 minute.
- Review quality, pacing, and style against your preferences.
- Use a simple 1–5 scale to rate clarity, detail, and instruction-following.
Step 8: Interview Your Top Picks
Editing skill matters, but so does communication. A quick video call helps you judge reliability, responsiveness, and whether they’ll be easy to work with. This step is where you confirm if someone is a long-term partner, not just a freelancer.
How to run effective interviews:
- Keep calls short, 10–15 minutes is enough.
- Ask about their workflow, tools, and client experience.
- Notice how they communicate—clear, concise, and professional.
- Skip this step for quick, one-off projects where speed matters most.
Step 9: Onboard the Right Way
Even great editors need direction. Without a clear onboarding process, you’ll waste time fixing mistakes and repeating instructions. A simple system upfront ensures consistency, protects your ownership rights, and gives editors what they need to succeed.
How to onboard smoothly:
- Document your process in a one-page guide covering tools, deadlines, and file handling.
- Share style rules and examples so they understand your brand.
- Use contracts that confirm you own all final content.
- Start with a one-month trial, offering support early, then stepping back to review results.
Step 10: Always Hire Two Editors at First
Relying on one editor creates risk. People get sick, miss deadlines, or simply move on. By starting with two, you protect your workflow, keep projects moving, and learn who truly fits your business long term.
Why two is better than one:
- You have backup if one editor is unavailable.
- You can test capacity by splitting projects.
- Comparing results side by side shows who performs best.
- You can keep your top choice—or retain both for ongoing coverage.
Mistakes and Myths to Avoid
- Don’t hire based only on a portfolio. Portfolios can be padded or recycled.
- Don’t ask for free tests. The best editors will walk away.
- Don’t skip onboarding. Even a basic checklist avoids confusion.
- Don’t rely on one editor. Always keep a backup to avoid bottlenecks.
- Be wary of “unlimited revisions.” It often signals sloppy work, not good service.
Mini-FAQ
Q: Do I need complex project tools to manage editors?
A: No. Google Drive and email are enough if you stay consistent. If you grow, tools like ClickUp or Trello help.
Q: Should I hire overseas or local editors?
A:
Both work. Focus on quality, communication, and reliability, not just price or location.
Q: What’s a fair rate for a paid test?
A:
For a 1-minute edit, $10–$50 is standard, depending on complexity. Never ask for free edits.
Q: How do I avoid endless revision loops?
A:
Share clear instructions and a style guide from the start. Keep feedback focused on preferences, not basics.
Q: What if my first editor isn’t a fit?
A: That’s why you hire two or more at first. Thank them, pay fairly, and move the work to your backup.
Ready to grow your business with YouTube?
Stop guessing and start using a proven system. Get instant access to our free YouTube masterclass and learn how to turn YouTube into a predictable source of leads and authority.
